First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
 
print this   Print         E-mail this article  E-mail this article

House votes to restrict students from MySpace

By David L. Hudson Jr.
First Amendment Center research attorney
08.01.06

The House of Representatives has overwhelmingly passed the Deleting Online Predators Act, which would require public schools and libraries to block student access to commercial social-networking sites such as MySpace.com.

The measure passed 410-15 on July 26.

DOPA would require public schools and libraries receiving federal funds for Internet access to provide a “technology protection measure” for minors to protect them from harmful material on the Internet, including child pornography, material that is obscene or harmful to minors, or “commercial social networking website(s) or chat room(s) unless used for an educational purpose with adult supervision.”

As applied to libraries, the measure provides that the “technology protection measure” must protect “against access by minors without parental authorization to a commercial social networking website or chat room, and informs parents that sexual predators can use these websites and chatrooms to prey on children.”

According to the factual findings in the bill, sexual predators often “approach minors on the Internet using chat rooms and social networking websites” and that “one in five children has been approached sexually on the Internet.”

“I am extremely pleased that the House moved so quickly to pass this important legislation,” said the measure’s chief sponsor, Rep. Michael G. Fitzpatrick, R-Pa., in a press release. “This legislation is the first of its kind to address the growing use of social networking sites by sexual predators. Passage of the “Deleting Online Predators Act” demonstrates Congress’ commitment to safeguarding America’s families.”

Not everyone supports the proposed legislation. The American Library Association expressed disappointment July 26 at the House action.

“This unnecessary and overly broad legislation will hinder students’ ability to engage in distance learning and block library computer users from accessing a wide array of essential Internet applications including instant messaging, email, wikis and blogs,” said ALA president Leslie Burger in a news release.

“Under DOPA, people who use library and school computers as their primary conduits to the Internet will be unfairly blocked from accessing some of the web’s most powerful emerging technologies and learning applications,” Burger said. “As libraries are already required to block content that is “harmful to minors” under the Children’s Internet Protection Act (CIPA), DOPA is redundant and unnecessary legislation.”

Mark Uncapher, senior vice president and counsel for the Information Technology Association of America, also expressed opposition to DOPA.

"We have concerns that the legislation moved quickly without thorough committee review, particularly given existing law such as the Children’s Internet Protection Act," Uncapher said.

CIPA, which the U.S. Supreme Court upheld from First Amendment challenge in United States v. American Library Association (2003), requires public schools and libraries to adopt an Internet safety policy that protects minors from online obscenity, child pornography and other material harmful to minors.

ITAA's position is that DOPA provides less flexibility than CIPA and is redundant.

"We are concerned that DOPA would micromanage schools and libraries (in their) management of their E-Rate funded systems," Uncapher added. E-Rate is a federal program that makes some technologies more affordable for eligible schools and libraries.

The question now is whether a similar measure will be introduced for similarly quick passage in the Senate. Jeff Urbanchuk, Fitzpatrick’s press secretary, said House supporters were waiting for a companion bill to be introduced in the Senate. “We do think it will happen,” he said.


Previous
Bill seeks to shield kids from predators on social-networking sites
By David L. Hudson Jr. Congressional legislation would require public schools, libraries to prohibit children's access to sites like MySpace, Facebook. 06.07.06

Related

Student suspended for MySpace postings returns to school

Colorado high school agrees to remove any mention of punishment from 16-year-old's record after ACLU threatens to sue. 02.22.06

Educator sues students over MySpace page

San Antonio teens posted page in high school assistant principal's name, including obscene comments, pictures. 09.26.06

Ind. schools warn students to watch what they say online

Administrators say blog postings can be disruptive to education; critics say schools shouldn't be able to punish kids for comments posted off-campus. 10.02.06

Cop suspended over graphic MySpace site
Wichita Falls, Texas, city attorney says officer's Web page espoused fondness for violence that would hurt his testimony in criminal cases. 10.16.06

People reconsider posting personal details on public Web sites
'They're now more conscious that information they post online can be used in ways they didn't intend it to be,' says professor. 01.02.07

Families sue News Corp., MySpace after children abused
Lawsuits allege companies didn't do enough to prevent sexual predators from preying on underage daughters. 01.19.07

Lawmakers take aim at online predators
Bill would give social networking Web sites like MySpace access to database of sex offenders for checking names, addresses against public profiles. 01.31.07

Girl's MySpace posting is protected speech, Ind. appeals court rules
Lower court had placed A.B. on probation for expletive-laden entry criticizing school principal, body-piercings policy. 04.10.07

N.C. official targets social-networking Web sites
State attorney general joins lawmakers, others nationwide in push to ensure minors' safety online, but security, First Amendment experts question value of singling out sites like MySpace.com. 07.17.07

Indecency online

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.



Last system update: Friday, September 10, 2010 | 15:47:41
 SEARCH  MORE
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
How to contribute
Video/RSS/podcasts
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment
reports

Religious liberty in public schools
First Reports
Supreme Court
Columnists
Experts
First Amendment publications
1 for All
First Amendment Center history
Glossary
Freedom Sings™
Events
Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
The First Amendment
Library

Lesson plans
freedomforum.org
Newseum
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links